Skip to main content
Buying Guide

Printer Toner and Ink: Genuine, Compatible and Surplus Explained

13 November 2026

Genuine, compatible, remanufactured, surplus: printer supplies come in more varieties than the box suggests. What each one is, how long cartridges keep, and how to make sure you buy the right one.

Printer supplies are one of the most confusing things to buy online. The same cartridge can be listed as genuine, original, compatible, remanufactured or surplus, at prices that vary several times over. Here is what those words actually mean, and what to check before you buy.

Genuine, compatible and remanufactured

Genuine (or "original", "OEM") cartridges are made by the printer's own manufacturer and sold in its branded packaging. They cost the most new, and they are what the printer was designed around.

Compatible cartridges are new cartridges made by a third party to fit a particular printer. Quality varies from maker to maker. The good ones print well; the poor ones can give weaker colours, smear, or not be recognised by the printer at all.

Remanufactured cartridges are used genuine shells that have been cleaned, refilled and re-sold. They are cheaper again, and often the most environmentally sensible choice, but the result depends heavily on who did the work.

Where surplus fits in

Surplus toner and ink is usually genuine, boxed stock that a business no longer needs. A company changes its printers, a contract ends, an office closes, and the cupboard of spare cartridges goes up for sale. It is new and genuine, and it is cheap only because the original buyer no longer has the printer it fits.

That makes surplus genuine stock some of the best value in printer supplies, as long as it is the right cartridge and has been stored properly.

Does toner go off?

Sealed toner keeps well. It is a dry powder, and in its original sealed packaging, stored somewhere cool and dry and out of direct sunlight, it usually prints normally years later. Many manufacturers print an "install by" or "use by" date on the box, which is a sensible guide rather than a cliff edge.

Ink is more sensitive. Liquid ink can thicken or dry over time, especially once the seal is broken. With ink cartridges, the date on the box matters more, and an opened cartridge should be used soon.

Things worth checking on any surplus cartridge:

  • The packaging is sealed, or the description says clearly if it has been opened.
  • The date on the box, where there is one.
  • The cartridge has been kept indoors. Damp and heat do far more harm than age.

Make sure it is the right cartridge

The most common mistake is buying a cartridge that looks right and is not. Check:

  • The cartridge number, not just the printer model. One printer can take several cartridges (standard and high-yield, black and colour), and one cartridge number can fit several printers.
  • The colour code. Toner usually comes as K (black), C (cyan), M (magenta) and Y (yellow).
  • Standard or high capacity. High-yield cartridges print more pages and usually cost more. Make sure you are comparing like with like.
  • Region. Some ink cartridges are coded to the region the printer was sold in and will not work in a printer from elsewhere. Surplus stock from a UK business is normally UK stock, but it is worth asking if the box looks unfamiliar.

The cartridge number is printed on the old cartridge and in the printer's manual, and usually on a label inside the printer's front cover.

Your rights when buying

Buying from a UK business, goods must be as described, of satisfactory quality and fit for purpose under the Consumer Rights Act 2015. For online purchases you also normally have 14 days from delivery to change your mind. A cartridge described as new and sealed should arrive new and sealed.

Browse printer supplies

We list surplus toner and ink individually, photographed as it is, with the cartridge number in the title so it is easy to match to your printer. Have a look in computers, tablets and networking and business, office and industrial, or ask us if you are not sure a cartridge fits.